Why insurers pulling out is a problem
It’s common practice for mortgage lenders to require borrowers to have homeowners insurance in place before giving out loans. But the requirement to carry homeowners insurance doesn’t end there.
You’re typically required to maintain homeowners insurance while you’re in the process of paying off your mortgage. If your insurance is canceled, your mortgage lender will typically be notified. If you don’t then find replacement insurance, your lender could compel you to use insurance it procures for you, known as force-placed insurance.
The problem, though, is that this type of insurance is generally more expensive than the insurance you might find on your own. So it's not a great option.
And that assumes it even is an option. If your mortgage lender can’t procure insurance for you, you risk having your mortgage go into default, leading to foreclosure.
But with more insurance companies pulling out of disaster-prone states, homeowners’ options for coverage are getting whittled down.
The New York Times reports that in Florida, nonrenewals more than doubled in 2022 after massive insurer losses from Hurricane Ian. Florida has the highest nonrenewal rates in the U.S.
In Louisiana, nonrenewal rates were the second-highest in the country in 2023. The state’s low-lying coast makes it prone to hurricane damage.
Texas, too, has seen fluctuating nonrenewal rates. And in 2024, Progressive became the fifth major insurer to end or limit coverage within the state.
In California, nonrenewal rates soared in 2023, particularly in wildfire-prone regions. Even before the early 2025 wildfires, a number of large insurers abandoned California, including Allstate, the Hartford, and State Farm.
Of course, some of this is understandable. Insurers had, as of early February, paid almost $7 billion in claims in response to the Los Angeles. wildfires. And Hurricane Ian’s price tag for insurers was projected to be a whopping $63 billion.
So there comes a point when homeowners insurance companies either need to pull out or start charging exorbitant rates. And it’s unclear as to which is the better scenario.
Invest in real estate without the headache of being a landlord
Imagine owning a portfolio of thousands of well-managed single family rentals or a collection of cutting-edge industrial warehouses. You can now gain access to a $1B portfolio of income-producing real estate assets designed to deliver long-term growth from the comforts of your couch.
The best part? You don’t have to be a millionaire and can start investing in minutes.
Learn MoreWhat do if your homeowners insurance is cancelled
If your homeowners insurance is cancelled, it’s important to find out why. If it’s due to a specific issue with your home, there may be steps you can take to remedy it. But if it’s part of a broad pullback at the county or state level, your options may be more limited.
You could, of course, shop for replacement insurance. But you may not have many affordable options.
In that situation, your best bet may be a FAIR Plan. Short for Fair Access to Insurance Requirements, FAIR programs are state-run and provide insurance coverage for homeowners who can’t get it the conventional way due to being in a high-risk area.
The problem, though, is that FAIR plans can be pretty basic, offering only coverage for dwelling and personal property. This means you may not be able to get loss of use or liability coverage through a FAIR plan.
Worse yet, FAIR plans commonly only insure homes at their cash value, as opposed to their replacement cost value — meaning, the amount of money it would take to rebuild. Such is the situation a good number of Los Angeles wildfire victims are in now, where they're entitled to some payout from their insurance, but not enough to rebuild the properties they’ve lost.
That’s why it’s extremely important to research insurance coverage options before buying a home. And if you find that your options are limited, consider it a red flag.
The richest 1% use an advisor. Do you?
Wealthy people know that having money is not the same as being good with money. Advisor.com can help you shape your financial future and connect with expert guidance . A trusted advisor helps you make smart choices about investments, retirement savings, and tax planning.
Try it now
