Atlanta woman follows advice of used car salesman, falls prey to insurance scam after missing this major red flag — and she’s not the only one

How the insurance scam unfolded

Rucker sent the initial $250 payment, continued to pay the fee via Cash App and assumed she had coverage.

The real trouble began months later when she was in a car accident and tried to file a claim with her supposed insurance company. After requesting a $500 deductible for the claim, which Rucker paid, the company stopped responding. It was then she realized she'd been scammed out of nearly $2,000.

Investigators from Georgia’s Commissioner of Insurance and Fire Safety later confirmed that the company was not a valid insurer and had been part of an ongoing fraudulent scheme dating back to 2022. The thief behind this scam had allegedly tricked at least 19 people out of $17,600 total across the state by requesting victims to pay for “insurance” through Cash App and pocketing the cash.

Once ANF informed the Commissioner of Insurance about the scam, it issued Atlanta Best Used Cars a cease and desist order to stop the dealership from referring customers “to any agent or entity without first establishing that such agent or entity is licensed to transact the business of insurance in Georgia.”

Luckily for Rucker, the insurance company of the at-fault vehicle in the accident covered her auto repairs, and she was able to get her car fixed.

Stop overpaying for home insurance

Home insurance is an essential expense – one that can often be pricey. You can lower your monthly recurring expenses by finding a more economical alternative for home insurance.

Officialhomeinsurance can help you do just that. Their online marketplace of vetted home insurance providers allows you to quickly shop around for rates from the country’s top insurance companies, and ensure you’re paying the lowest price possible for your home insurance.

Explore better rates

How to shop for insurance safely

There are several steps you can take to protect yourself from falling victim to a scam like this.

First, always verify that the car insurance company you are considering is licensed to operate in your state. You can typically verify this information with your state's department of insurance.

In Georgia, you can use the License Lookup service offered by the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance and Safety Fire.

Also, be wary of agencies that ask you to pay by peer-to-peer payment apps like Cash App, Apple Pay or Venmo. These payment methods are intended to send funds to friends or family and lack the fraud protections of traditional payment methods like ACH transfers or credit cards.

Rucker has since reported the scam to multiple agencies, including the Consumer Protection Division, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Better Business Bureau.

"Every late night that I was up, just trying to find out any type of information that I could find… it's worth it,” Rucker told an ANF reporter. “If it's going to stop someone from making the same mistake I made, it's definitely worth it."